Match My FoundationConversions › Fenty to Maybelline SuperStay

Fenty to Maybelline SuperStay Shade Converter

Every Fenty shade matched to its closest Maybelline SuperStay equivalent by depth + undertone.

Fenty Pro Filt'rMaybelline SuperStay matchMatch
110
Depth 1.5 · Cool
102 Fair Porcelain
Depth 1.5 · Neutral
91%
150
Depth 2.0 · Neutral
110 Porcelain
Depth 2.0 · Warm
91%
180
Depth 2.5 · Warm
110 Porcelain
Depth 2.0 · Warm
88%
220
Depth 3.5 · Warm
128 Warm Nude
Depth 3.5 · Warm
100%
240
Depth 4.0 · Cool
120 Classic Ivory
Depth 3.0 · Neutral
68%
290
Depth 5.0 · Warm
220 Natural Beige
Depth 4.5 · Warm
88%
330
Depth 6.0 · Neutral
310 Sun Beige
Depth 6.0 · Neutral
100%
385
Depth 7.0 · Warm
330 Toffee
Depth 7.0 · Neutral
91%
420
Depth 8.0 · Cool
355 Coconut
Depth 8.0 · Neutral
91%
460
Depth 9.0 · Warm
360 Mocha
Depth 9.0 · Warm
100%
490
Depth 10.0 · Neutral
375 Java
Depth 10.0 · Neutral
100%
Try the interactive matcher — compare all 12 brands at once
💡 Pro tip: Matches above 90% are usually spot-on. Below that, check the undertone pill — a Warm→Cool jump matters more than half a depth step. Always swatch in natural daylight.

How these matches are calculated

Every shade is mapped to a shared system: depth (1 = fairest, 10 = deepest) and undertone (Cool, Neutral, Warm, or Olive). The converter finds the Maybelline SuperStay shade closest in depth, weighted 70%, and undertone compatibility, weighted 30%. It's the same engine behind our interactive matcher.

Two caveats: brands classify undertones differently (MAC's NC/NW runs opposite to most), and formulas oxidize differently — a matte formula can darken 1–2 levels over a few hours.

FAQ

How accurate is this Fenty to Maybelline SuperStay conversion?
Each match is scored on depth (how light or dark) and undertone compatibility. Matches above 90% are usually very close; between 80–90% expect a slight difference in undertone or depth. Formula differences (matte vs dewy) and oxidation also affect how a shade looks on skin, so always swatch in natural daylight before buying full size.
My Fenty shade isn't listed — what do I do?
This chart covers the most-searched Fenty shades. If yours is missing, pick the closest neighboring shade with the same undertone — your Maybelline SuperStay match will be nearly identical. You can also use the interactive matcher on our homepage.
Can I convert Maybelline SuperStay back to Fenty?
Yes — see the reverse chart: Maybelline SuperStay to Fenty. Note that reverse matches aren't always symmetrical, because each brand has different shade ranges and gaps.

More conversions